Managers and Engineers: Impact of Defined Roles on Shared Leadership in Capstone Design

Rebecca Komarek; Daria A Kotys-Schwartz; Daniel Knight; Julie Elizabeth Steinbrenner

Download Paper | Permalink

Conference: 2023 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition
Location: Baltimore , Maryland
Publication Date: June 25, 2023
Start Date: June 25, 2023
End Date: June 28, 2023
Conference Session: Design in Engineering Education Division (DEED) Technical Session 8
Tagged Division: Design in Engineering Education Division (DEED)
Page Count: 16
DOI: 10.18260/1-2--43533
Permanent URL: https://peer.asee.org/43533
Download Count: 117

Request a correction

Paper Authors

biography

Rebecca Komarek University of Colorado Boulder

visit author page

Rebecca Komarek is the Associate Director of the Idea Forge at the University of Colorado Boulder. She has taught in the areas of education research, leadership development, and engineering design both at the undergraduate and graduate levels. Her background includes BS and MS degrees in structural engineering and education. She earned her PhD in engineering education with a focus on leadership development.

visit author page

biography

Daria A Kotys-Schwartz University of Colorado Boulder

visit author page

Daria Kotys-Schwartz is the Director of the Idea Forge—a flexible, cross-disciplinary design space at University of Colorado Boulder. She is also the Design Center Colorado Director of Undergraduate Programs and a Teaching Professor in the Department of Mechanical Engineering. She received B.S. and M.S degrees in mechanical engineering  from The Ohio State University and a Ph.D. in mechanical engineering from the University of Colorado Boulder. Kotys-Schwartz has focused her research in engineering student learning, retention, and student identity development within the context of engineering design. She is currently investigating the impact of cultural norms in an engineering classroom context, performing comparative studies between engineering education and professional design practices, examining holistic approaches to student retention, and exploring informal learning in engineering education.

visit author page

biography

Daniel Knight University of Colorado Boulder

visit author page

Daniel W. Knight is the Program Assessment and Research Associate at Design Center (DC) Colorado in CUâ€™s Department of Mechanical Engineering at the College of Engineering and Applied Science. He holds a B.A. in psychology from Louisiana State Universit

visit author page

biography

Julie Elizabeth Steinbrenner University of Colorado Boulder

visit author page

Julie Steinbrenner earned her PhD in Mechanical Engineering at Stanford University in 2011. She is currently an Associate Teaching Professor in the Department of Mechanical Engineering at University of Colorado Boulder, where she teaches Senior Design and thermo-fluids courses. Her teaching philosophy focuses on student preparation for engineering practice -- incorporating industry and alumni interactions into curricular and co-curricular activities.

visit author page

Download Paper | Permalink

Abstract

Exploration of role assignment in engineering design teams on leadership

Over the last 20 years, engineering educators have realized the importance of building leadership skills among engineering students. This movement is evidenced by the creation of dozens of engineering leadership programs that offer classes, certificates, minors, and even a Bachelor of Science in engineering leadership. Despite these initiatives, research shows that professional engineers do not view engineering as a leadership profession [1]. ABET and industry agree that engineering students should intentionally develop leadership skills during college. This study explores leadership concepts within capstone engineering teams. The aim of this study is to learn how the assignment of project roles in engineering capstone design teams influences leadership skills such as accountability, communicating a vision, teamwork, role identity, and management, along with measures of leader effectiveness. The research is situated within the capstone design context at a large mountain-region flagship university. In this class, a group of 6-7 senior engineering students work together to complete an industry-sponsored design project.

The topic will be explored through a shared leadership lens [2], to understand the roles correlated with leadership skills and the links between role assignment and the students' level of leadership effectiveness. The goal with this proposed project is to determine how these role assignments contribute to the leadership development of engineering students. We explore this topic by analyzing data previously gathered in the course survey given to all enrolled students, approximately 230 students a year. This robust final survey has questions related to desired learning outcomes for the course, many of which are leadership skills in team settings. Additionally, survey results explore leadership effectiveness using the Competing Values Framework (CVF). As summarized in Redacted et al., [3] the CVF highlights four leadership orientations: Collaborate, Create, Control, and Compete [4]. The key tenant of the CVF is behavioral complexity, which is defined as the ability to implement various leadership orientations, depending on the needs of a given situation. Instead of identifying a person’s behaviors as aligning with one orientation, the empirically tested theory equates effective leadership to the ability to implement various leadership behaviors as needed. Research in professional business settings shows that individuals who are the most effective leaders have competence in all four leadership orientations [5]. We explore both leadership skills and behavioral complexity (and therefore leadership effectiveness) for students based on their assigned role in their capstone design project team.

Research questions: 1. Do students perceive assigned roles contribute the to development of their leadership skills 2. Is this moderated by students’ leadership styles using the CVF perspective?

This study highlights a new direction for leadership in capstone design teams. While the concept of shared leadership in this context is not new, few other capstone design programs focus student work using role assignment. Little research has been done on the outcomes related to leadership in specific role assignment within engineering student teams, despite common role identification in a typical engineering industry setting. We expect that this exploratory study will lead us to pursue future investigation into the connections between role assignments and leadership skills, potentially leveraging theories from both engineering and leadership identity development (and their intersectionality), role identity development, and motivation.

Preliminary results indicate that students perceive a positive impact of assigned roles on their leadership skill development. Additional results will be discussed in the paper.

C. Rottmann, R. Sacks, D. Reeve, Engineering leadership: Grounding leadership theory in engineers’ professional identities, Leadership, 11(3), pp. 351–373, 2015. Redacted, International Journal of Engineering Education, 2019. Redacted, ASEE Conference Proceedings, 2022. K. S. Cameron, R. E. Quinn, J. DeGraff, and A. V. Thakor, Competing Values Leadership, 2nd ed. Northampton, MA, USA: Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc., 2014. K. A. Lawrence, P. Lenk, and R. E. Quinn, “Behavioral complexity in leadership: The psychometric properties of a new instrument to measure behavioral repertoire,” Leadership Quarterly, vol. 20, pp. 87-102. 2009.

Citation
Format

Komarek, R., & Kotys-Schwartz, D. A., & Knight, D., & Steinbrenner, J. E. (2023, June), Managers and Engineers: Impact of Defined Roles on Shared Leadership in Capstone Design Paper presented at 2023 ASEE Annual Conference & Exposition, Baltimore , Maryland. 10.18260/1-2--43533

TY - CPAPER
AB - Exploration of role assignment in engineering design teams on leadership

Over the last 20 years, engineering educators have realized the importance of building leadership skills among engineering students. This movement is evidenced by the creation of dozens of engineering leadership programs that offer classes, certificates, minors, and even a Bachelor of Science in engineering leadership. Despite these initiatives, research shows that professional engineers do not view engineering as a leadership profession [1]. ABET and industry agree that engineering students should intentionally develop leadership skills during college. This study explores leadership concepts within capstone engineering teams.

The aim of this study is to learn how the assignment of project roles in engineering capstone design teams influences leadership skills such as accountability, communicating a vision, teamwork, role identity, and management, along with measures of leader effectiveness. The research is situated within the capstone design context at a large mountain-region flagship university. In this class, a group of 6-7 senior engineering students work together to complete an industry-sponsored design project.

The topic will be explored through a shared leadership lens [2], to understand the roles correlated with leadership skills and the links between role assignment and the students&#39; level of leadership effectiveness. The goal with this proposed project is to determine how these role assignments contribute to the leadership development of engineering students. We explore this topic by analyzing data previously gathered in the course survey given to all enrolled students, approximately 230 students a year. This robust final survey has questions related to desired learning outcomes for the course, many of which are leadership skills in team settings. Additionally, survey results explore leadership effectiveness using the Competing Values Framework (CVF). As summarized in Redacted et al., [3] the CVF highlights four leadership orientations: Collaborate, Create, Control, and Compete [4]. The key tenant of the CVF is behavioral complexity, which is defined as the ability to implement various leadership orientations, depending on the needs of a given situation. Instead of identifying a person’s behaviors as aligning with one orientation, the empirically tested theory equates effective leadership to the ability to implement various leadership behaviors as needed. Research in professional business settings shows that individuals who are the most effective leaders have competence in all four leadership orientations [5]. We explore both leadership skills and behavioral complexity (and therefore leadership effectiveness) for students based on their assigned role in their capstone design project team.

Research questions:
1. Do students perceive assigned roles contribute the to development of their leadership skills
2. Is this moderated by students’ leadership styles using the CVF perspective?

This study highlights a new direction for leadership in capstone design teams. While the concept of shared leadership in this context is not new, few other capstone design programs focus student work using role assignment. Little research has been done on the outcomes related to leadership in specific role assignment within engineering student teams, despite common role identification in a typical engineering industry setting. We expect that this exploratory study will lead us to pursue future investigation into the connections between role assignments and leadership skills, potentially leveraging theories from both engineering and leadership identity development (and their intersectionality), role identity development, and motivation.

Preliminary results indicate that students perceive a positive impact of assigned roles on their leadership skill development. Additional results will be discussed in the paper.

C. Rottmann, R. Sacks, D. Reeve, Engineering leadership: Grounding leadership theory in engineers’ professional identities, Leadership, 11(3), pp. 351–373, 2015.
Redacted, International Journal of Engineering Education, 2019.
Redacted, ASEE Conference Proceedings, 2022.
K. S. Cameron, R. E. Quinn, J. DeGraff, and A. V. Thakor, Competing Values Leadership, 2nd ed. Northampton, MA, USA: Edward Elgar Publishing, Inc., 2014.
K. A. Lawrence, P. Lenk, and R. E. Quinn, “Behavioral complexity in leadership: The psychometric properties of a new instrument to measure behavioral repertoire,” Leadership Quarterly, vol. 20, pp. 87-102. 2009.

AU - Rebecca Komarek
AU - Daria A Kotys-Schwartz
AU - Daniel Knight
AU - Julie Elizabeth Steinbrenner
CY - Baltimore , Maryland
DA - 2023/06/25
PB - ASEE Conferences
TI - Managers and Engineers: Impact of Defined Roles on Shared Leadership in Capstone Design
UR - https://peer.asee.org/43533
DO - 10.18260/1-2--43533
ER -